Terry McDonell, a respected editor since the 1970s, has played a significant role in shaping magazines like Rolling Stone, Outside, Esquire, Men’s Journal, and Sports Illustrated. He has had the privilege of working with iconic writers such as Hunter S. Thompson and George Plimpton in a realm where literary ambitions and journalistic pursuits intertwine. McDonell has seamlessly transitioned from the era of traditional print magazines to the digital age, demonstrating adaptability and success in both realms, notably increasing digital revenue during his tenure at Sports Illustrated.
In his book, The Accidental Life: An Editor’s Notes on Writing and Writers, McDonell captures a deeper past with insightful and concise writing, portraying personalities with swift strokes without unnecessary embellishments. His encounters with notable figures like George Plimpton and Kurt Vonnegut are vividly depicted, showcasing his keen observation and admiration for their unique traits.
The book is structured as a collection of memories and observations, each section ending with -ENDIT-, framing the anecdotes with titles and word counts that reflect his editorial background. While McDonell acknowledges the past culture of excess and masculinity prevalent among writers like Hunter S. Thompson, he also acknowledges the evolving landscape of inclusivity and gender equality in editorial roles.
McDonell’s genuine appreciation for the writers he has worked with shines through in his writing, offering nuanced insights into their craft and personalities. His narrative delicately reveals the essence of each writer without delving into exploitation. McDonell’s own prose serves as a platform to highlight the talents and complexities of others, as seen in his commentary on Thomas McGuane’s unexpected exploration of clinical depression in a Sports Illustrated piece.
Through his reflections on the world of magazines, writing, and collaborative efforts with writers, McDonell presents a heartfelt and insightful perspective. By grounding his discussions in personal relationships and individual stories, McDonell infuses The Accidental Life with a captivating resonance. His foundational principles of editing – “Force nothing. Be clear. You can always go deeper” – encapsulate the essence of his book.
