In the story “The Prairie Wife” from Curtis Sittenfeld’s latest collection, the character Kirsten feels envious of her friend Casey, wishing she could let go of grudges and live more freely. This theme of insecurities and social standings continues throughout the stories, with characters reflecting on their teenage years well into adulthood. Sittenfeld’s writing is sharp, witty, and confident, bringing humor and empathy to these tales of missed opportunities and failures.
The last story, “Do-Over,” delves into a conflict from senior year that resurfaces years later, showcasing how past experiences can continue to shape our identities. The characters grapple with issues of beauty and self-worth, highlighting the lasting impact of societal standards. The desire to be noticed and remembered is a common thread among Sittenfeld’s characters, reflecting on the complexities of human relationships and perceptions.
While some stories like “A Regular Couple” explore themes of success and resentment, others like “Off the Record” touch on the importance of recognition and self-doubt. Sittenfeld masterfully weaves together moments of humor, anxiety, and intelligence in her storytelling, creating a diverse and engaging collection. Each narrative offers a unique perspective on love, beauty, and the pursuit of acceptance.
Despite some recurring themes, Sittenfeld’s skillful prose and varied storytelling keep the collection fresh and engaging. “Volunteers Are Shining Stars” stands out for its departure from the usual settings, offering a different take on beauty and judgment. Through her characters’ struggles with self-image and relationships, Sittenfeld portrays the enduring power of beauty and its influence on our lives.
